Globe Valve Internals Damaged due to High Side-Load Forces

Figure 1: Y-Pattern Globe Valve
Figure 1: Y-Pattern Globe Valve

Globe valves are used to isolate steam lines in power plants in the event of a pipe break; such pipe breaks are referred to as High Energy Line Breaks (HELB).

KEI performed a Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) for a Y-pattern globe valve that operated in the High-Pressure Coolant Injection System. The purpose of the FMEA was to determine the possible failure modes that might prevent the valve from closing and isolating under HELB conditions. The Y-pattern globe valve (Figure 1) comprised three internal body-ribs that guided the plug. The valve differential pressure conditions and associated high plug-to-guide-rib loading and possible plug-to-guide-rib galling, or guide-rib damage were identified as possible failure mechanisms.

The subject valve was tested under HELB conditions (see Figure 2) to determine if plug-to-rib galling or rib damage occurred and whether the damage would result in an increase in required thrust that would prevent the operator from actuating the valve to the fully closed position.

Valve testing under HELB conditions confirmed that the subject valve was susceptible to plug-to-rib damage for certain plug geometries in certain flow orientations. The flow-under orientation was determined to be the most severe for this particular valve. Figure 3 shows the guide-rib damage (on the 120°and -120° rib) caused by the high side load forces that occur under HELB conditions. Figure 4 shows corresponding damage on the leading edge of the plug.

To support the FMEA and root-cause analysis, KEI developed an analytical model based on plug geometry and operating conditions was developed to predict the thrust required to operate the valve and plug-to-rib loading in the presence of flow-induced side-load forces. The analytical model utilized fluid-force coefficients based on Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analysis. The CFD-based fluid force model was used to perform Finite Element Analysis (FEA) of the plug-to-guide rib reaction. The flow test data validated the CFD analysis and verified that FEA could be used to predict guide rib damage for other plug geometries and system conditions.

Figure 2: Flow Loop Testing of a Y-pattern Globe Valve Closing against a High Energy Line Break

Figure 2: Flow Loop Testing of a Y-pattern Globe Valve Closing against a High Energy Line Break

 

Figure 3: Guide-Rib Damage Due to Valve Closing under High Energy Line Break Conditions

a) Guide Rib at -120°
b) Guide Rib at 0°
c) Guide Rib at 120°
Figure 3: Guide-Rib Damage Due to Valve Closing under High Energy Line Break Conditions

 

Figure 4: Plug Damage Due to High Deferential Pressure Conditions

Figure 4: Plug Damage Due to High Deferential Pressure Conditions